Forum Login

Been There — Done That

It's Been Done Before

We're all familiar with the phrase, "Been there, done that". It is often pronounced by the world-weary and self-proclaimed sophisticates who feel that there's nothing new under the sun.

For some photographers there's a corollary to this — "It's all been done before by someone else." They ask themselves (or are asked rhetorically by others) — does the world need another photograph of Antelope Canyon, Yosemite, a Bald Eagle in a Tree? —  or name your own photographic cliché.

Some find it hard to answer such a loaded question, and in fact many turn away from pursuing their hobby or their art because when faced with this question the following answer usually comes up. No, the world probably doesn't need another image of The Grand Canyon or a frost-covered Elk in the snowy fog of Yellowstone in winter.

Behindyou, Yellowstone, Feb. 2002
Pentax 67II with Pentax 400mm f/4 ED(IF) lens on Provia 100F

In fact there is quite a vocal movement that says that there is now such a surfeit of wildlife photographs of almost every species and every locale that there should be a photographic moratorium declared.

What rubbish!

This reminds me of the true story of the British commissioner of patents in the late 19th century who advised the government that the Patent Office should be soon closed because just about everything that could be invented already had been.

With this in mind here is my response to either the moderates who express dismay that "Everything has already been done", or to the extremist who ask that wildlife photography be put on hold.

But Not By Me!

Yes, this type of photograph may have been done countless times before, but not by me!

I want to do it for the pleasure that the act of doing so provides. I want to experience the challenge. I want to see if I can do it better than it's been done before. Even if my effort doesn't produce an image worthy of anything more than a smile as I view it on the lightbox and then relegate it to a filing cabinet, it's worthwhile because I did it, and I was there

Dune Trees — October, 2001

Photographed with a Hasselblad ArcBody and 35mm Rodenstock lens on Provia 100F.

The tonic that I prescribe to someone feeling the weltschmertz of photography — the over-familiarity of the all-too-famous locations and overly-familiar images — is, break the mold. Go to places that are off the beaten path. Try techniques that are off-beat. Force yourself to use lenses or methods that make you see things in novel ways. Shoot locations that call for a long-lens with a wide angle, and vice-versa.

Seeking Similarities

And AND — Upstate New York, 1995
Taken with a Mamiya 645 and 150mm lens

Driving through a heavily forested area of upstate New York in 1995 I came across this deserted crane and sign.  It didn't appear as if anyone had paid attention to it in years.  The question has always haunted me — and what?

Truck and Sign, New York: Walker Evans — 1930

Was I influenced by Walker Evan's famous photograph from 1930? I certainly knew the image. But, was I thinking of it when I shot "And"? I don't remember it being so, but it doesn't matter. Evans' photograph is and always will be superior to and better known than mine. Does it matter to me? Not a bit! I still love the whimsy of my "And".

The Art of Doing

  Dawn — White Sands

Pentax 67II and 55~100mm f/4.5 zoom. Provia 100F. 

The final image that you produce is only one part of the reason for doing photography. Make the act of creation — the doing of it — an end unto itself. By doing this you will free yourself not only from the shackles of conformity, but you'll also possibly create something that no one else has ever seen before.


Filed Under:  
Essays   

show page metadata

Concepts: Photography, Camera, Grand Canyon, Photograph, Want, Image, Photographic lens, 19th century

Entities: New York, Pentax, Grand Canyon, Michael Reichmann, Walker Evans, Walker Evan

Tags: photograph, image, walker evan, New York, late 19th century, upstate new york, self-proclaimed sophisticates, photography, snowy fog, loaded question, Pentax 67II, countless times, frost-covered elk, beaten path, following answer, photographic moratorium, Rodenstock lens, Bald Eagle, photographic clichu00e9, filing cabinet, Antelope Canyon, British commissioner, novel ways, true story, Dune Trees, Patent Office, Hasselblad ArcBody, Grand Canyon, vocal movement, overly-familiar images, wildlife photographs, famous photograph, all-too-famous locations, wildlife photography, wide angle, Shoot locations, final image, Yellowstone, patent, Provia