2 shots fro Culzean shore can't choose?

[Locheil]

Hi All,
I would appreciate feed back from the forum members on these 2 shots taken on the shore at Culzean, Aryshire, Scotland. The two shots are similar, only the foreground varies slightly by repositioning, & I'm stuck as know which I prefer?

Regards,
Alan Cameron


Alan Cameron Images


[attachment=7871:attachment]

[attachment=7872:attachment]

[DarkPenguin]

Hi All,
I would appreciate feed back from the forum members on these 2 shots taken on the shore at Culzean, Aryshire, Scotland. The two shots are similar, only the foreground varies slightly by repositioning, & I'm stuck as know which I prefer?

Regards,
Alan Cameron
Alan Cameron Images
[attachment=7871:attachment]

[attachment=7872:attachment]
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=214303\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

The bottom one.  Less of the dark wedge of beach.  (I might even crop a touch from the right.)  I also like the little details in the foreground.

[Eric Myrvaagnes]

I agree. The balance is better in the second, and there is more interesting stuff going on in the foreground.

[iancl]

I agree: the bottom one. Not only does it offer a less divisive foreground, it also has a better texture for the sand and pebbles which melds into the mid-ground wave texture more cohesively.

[wolfnowl]

Definitely the second of the two, for reasons already mentioned.

Mike.

[Locheil]

Thanks Guys,

I'm comming around to your way of thinking.... picture 2 is the better of the images.

Regards

Alan