rolling chocolate

[kikashi]

Preference? Comments?

Jeremy

[Slobodan Blagojevic]

#2

Slightly better (more balanced) composition and more visible light/shadow interplay. Slightly more abstract as well.

[sdwilsonsct]

I'd like the forms in #1, especially the zig-zag, with the light and composition in #2.

[shaunw]

Interesting shots almost abstract...again not a great deal in it, for me the 2nd shot has a better tonal range helped out by the shadows, i think the textures come across a little better in the 2nd as well.

[Eric Myrvaagnes]

I like both, but the second wins for me: more interesting, balanced composition.

[churly]

A bit late to the vote but I actually prefer the composition in #1 because of the intersection of the 2 diagonals and the vertical near the top right 3rd point.  I do prefer the tonality of #2.

[francois]

I prefer #2. I like how the shadows play with the eroded surface of the angled rocks.

[kikashi]

Thanks, all. I had a vague preference for #2 but you've hardened it.

Jeremy